UPDATE: Jury finds Smith guilty of involuntary manslaughter - WVVA TV Bluefield Beckley WV News, Weather and Sports

UPDATE: Jury finds Smith guilty of involuntary manslaughter

Posted:
Antonio Smith Antonio Smith
Ira Harris Ira Harris
  • More Local NewsMore Local NewsMore>>

  • Probable cause found in beating case

    Probable cause found in beating case

    Manuel WilliamsManuel Williams
    RALEIGH COUNTY- (WVVA) One of two man accused of attacking a man inside his own home was in court for his preliminary hearing. Manuel Williams, 39, appeared in magistrate court in Raleigh County...More >>
    RALEIGH COUNTY- (WVVA) One of two man accused of attacking a man inside his own home was in court for his preliminary hearing. Manuel Williams, 39, appeared in magistrate court in Raleigh County...More >>
  • Businesses in Bluefield West Virginia

    Businesses in Bluefield West Virginia

    BLUEFIELD (WVVA)- A couple of fast food chains in Bluefield,West Virginia are no longer on Cumberland Ave. Wendy's closed for financial reasonsand according to Mark Meachum, President of the Bluefield Chamber of Commerce, "Arby's as you're aware, the franchisee claimed bankruptcy in a number of Arbys."Not all businesses in Bluefield are having a hard time.Ahmed Anu the owner of Portobella's says, "Just right now I think to myself, business is good. We did good."His Italian restaurant has been...More >>
    BLUEFIELD (WVVA)- A couple of fast food chains in Bluefield,West Virginia are no longer on Cumberland Ave. Wendy's closed for financial reasonsand according to Mark Meachum, President of the Bluefield Chamber of Commerce, "Arby's as you're aware, the franchisee claimed bankruptcy in a number of Arbys."Not all businesses in Bluefield are having a hard time.Ahmed Anu the owner of Portobella's says, "Just right now I think to myself, business is good. We did good."His Italian restaurant has been...More >>
  • Police look for missing man

    Police look for missing man

    William "NIck" DanielWilliam "NIck" Daniel
    RALEIGH CO. (WVVA) – Police in Beckley are looking for a man who went missing last week.William “Nick” Daniel, 26, was last seen July 24...More >>
    RALEIGH CO. (WVVA) – Police in Beckley are looking for a man who went missing last week.William “Nick” Daniel, 26, was last seen July 24...More >>

LEWISBURG (WVVA) - A jury has found Antonio Smith guilty of involuntary manslaughter in the 2012 death of Ira Harris.

Smith was charged with voluntary manslaughter for the death of 23-year-old Harris, but was found guilty of the lesser charge of involuntary manslaughter.

The defense had argued that Smith did not intend to kill Harris when he shoved him, resulting in Harris falling down a steep flight of stairs at an apartment above a pub in Lewisburg.

WVVA's Kristen Conner was in the courtroom and will have more details and reaction to verdict coming up later online and on WVVA News at Noon.

----

LEWISBURG (WVVA) - Jury deliberations are underway in the manslaughter trial of Antonio Smith.

Smith is charged with voluntary manslaughter for the death of 23-year-old Ira Harris in February 2012.

It's alleged that Smith and Harris -- a performer at the Greenbrier at the time of his death -- argued before Harris was pushed down a steep flight of stairs at an apartment above a Lewisburg pub.

The defense argued that Smith did not intend to kill Harris.

WVVA's Kristen Conner is in court this morning and will provide new details when they become available.

----

LEWISBURG (WVVA) – A trial is underway for the man accused of pushing a local performer down a flight of stairs to his death.

Antonio Dewayne Smith is charged with voluntary manslaughter in the death of Ira Harris of Chesapeake, Va.

Harris was employed as a singer at the Greenbrier when Smith allegedly pushed him down the stairs of an apartment above the Irish Pub in Lewisburg, after a heated altercation if February 2012.

In the case, the defense argued that voluntary manslaughter is not a valid charge, reiterating that Smith did not intend to kill Harris.

Public Defender DeWhitt Daniel moved that the judge give a direct verdict, because he said the state didn't actually prove the manslaughter was a conscious choice Smith made at the time. Judge Pomponio dismissed that motion and the trial continued.

When Smith took the stand, he told the court he had become angry and acted without thinking. He cried, admitting that he pushed Harris, but telling the court he did not mean to kill him.

But the prosecution alleges that pushing Harris above those particular stairs-- being so steep-- is an act of intent in itself, and that he attempted to cause Harris harm out of anger.

Prosecutor Patrick Via asked his lead witness, a friend of Harris's, if Harris got into arguments often. She replied, "Ira doesn't get upset. He doesn't get mad."

She said she saw a hand coming from behind her, which pushed Ira and caused him to fall. She had looked back and seen Smith there, and known he did it. In court, she identified Smith as the same man she saw at the top of the stairs.

Lt. Dove with the Lewisburg Police Department, the lead investigator in the case, came to the stand for the prosecution. He read records from the state Medical Examiner about Harris's injuries. The medical examiner had cited cranio-cerebral, or brain and head injuries, as a result of his fall down the stairs. Harris also suffered severe facial injuries, including fractures of facial bones and the skull, and major swelling.

Witnesses described seeing him hit his head on the stairs on the way down.

Closing arguments are set to begin at 9 a.m. Friday. The jury is expected to also deliberate that day.

  • NEWSMore>>

  • Pro-coal rally held in Pittsburgh in wake of EPA hearings

    Pro-coal rally held in Pittsburgh in wake of EPA hearings

    PITTSBURGH (AP) -- More than 2,000 union workers and others organized by the coal industry in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia are rallying in Pittsburgh to oppose new proposed pollution regulations...More >>
    PITTSBURGH (AP) -- More than 2,000 union workers and others organized by the coal industry in Pennsylvania, Ohio and West Virginia are rallying in Pittsburgh to oppose new proposed pollution regulations...More >>
  • Back to School Bash planned for Hinton

    Back to School Bash planned for Hinton

    Hinton, WV – The REACHH-Family Resource Center, Children’s Home Society and Youth Opportunities are teaming up to sponsor the First Annual “Back to School BASH”. On Thursday, August 7, students in grades 6-12 are invited to the Memorial Building in Hinton from 6:00-8:00 pm for an evening of music (live DJ), food and snacks, a juice bar, door prizes and giveaways, a photo booth for candids of you and your friends and more. The first 100 students will receive book bags chocked full of school su...More >>
    Hinton, WV – The REACHH-Family Resource Center, Children’s Home Society and Youth Opportunities are teaming up to sponsor the First Annual “Back to School BASH”. On Thursday, August 7, students in grades 6-12 are invited to the Memorial Building in Hinton from 6:00-8:00 pm for an evening of music (live DJ), food and snacks, a juice bar, door prizes and giveaways, a photo booth for candids of you and your friends and more. The first 100 students will receive book bags chocked full of school su...More >>
  • Virginia sales tax holiday approaching

    Virginia sales tax holiday approaching

    Virginia is giving shoppers a break on buying back-to-school supplies. Gov. Terry McAuliffe's office says the annual back-to-school sales tax holiday will begin Friday and run through Sunday. During the three-day holiday, shoppers at retail stores statewide won't have to pay sales tax on notebooks, pens, calculators, binders and other school supplies priced up to $20. Shoes and most clothing items priced up to $100 also will be exempt from the sales tax. The Department of Taxation has posted ...More >>
    Virginia is giving shoppers a break on buying back-to-school supplies. Gov. Terry McAuliffe's office says the annual back-to-school sales tax holiday will begin Friday and run through Sunday. During the three-day holiday, shoppers at retail stores statewide won't have to pay sales tax on notebooks, pens, calculators, binders and other school supplies priced up to $20. Shoes and most clothing items priced up to $100 also will be exempt from the sales tax. The Department of Taxation has posted ...More >>
  • Single-vehicle accident backs up I-77 traffic for miles

    Single-vehicle accident backs up I-77 traffic for miles

    GHENT, W.Va. -- Traffic came to a halt on Interstate 77 Wednesday evening, just past the tollbooth.Emergency dispatchers tell WVVA a vehicle crashed near mile marker 35 around 6:30 p.m. Traffic was backed up for miles.There's no word on any injuries. Ghent Volunteer Fire Department and ambulance services responded.The scene was cleared a little before 8 p.m.More >>
    GHENT, W.Va. -- Traffic came to a halt on Interstate 77 Wednesday evening, just past the tollbooth.Emergency dispatchers tell WVVA a vehicle crashed near mile marker 35 around 6:30 p.m. Traffic was backed up for miles.There's no word on any injuries. Ghent Volunteer Fire Department and ambulance services responded.The scene was cleared a little before 8 p.m.More >>
  • DHHR workers picket outside agency

    DHHR workers picket outside agency

    Fayette Co. (WVVA) -Department of Health and Human Resource workers picket outside the agency’s office in Fayette County...More >>
    Fayette Co. (WVVA) -Department of Health and Human Resource workers picket outside the agency’s office in Fayette County...More >>
  • Additional Lane Closure Expected in East River Mountain Tunnel

    Additional Lane Closure Expected in East River Mountain Tunnel

    (WVVA)- Motorists traveling northbound through the East River Mountain Tunnel can expect some delays as more cleaning and repairs are made...More >>
    (WVVA)- Motorists traveling northbound through the East River Mountain Tunnel can expect some delays as more cleaning and repairs are made...More >>
  • Two Raleigh Co. communities to get new fire hydrants

    Two Raleigh Co. communities to get new fire hydrants

    Raleigh Co. (WVVA) –Two communities in Raleigh County are getting new fire hydrants...More >>
    Raleigh Co. (WVVA) –Two communities in Raleigh County are getting new fire hydrants...More >>
  • UPDATE: Nighttime lane closure expected for repairs on tunnel

    UPDATE: Nighttime lane closure expected for repairs on tunnel

    UPDATE: The West Virginia Division of Highways says motorists can still expect periodic lane closures over the next several weeks as work continues inside East River Mountain Tunnel.More >>
    UPDATE: The West Virginia Division of Highways says motorists can still expect periodic lane closures over the next several weeks as work continues inside East River Mountain Tunnel.More >>
Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WVVA.
All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, Terms of Service and Mobile Privacy Policy & Terms of Service.

Persons with disabilities who need assistance with issues relating to the content of this station's public inspection file should contact Administrative Assistant Audrey Sluss at (304) 324-0659. Questions or concerns relating to the accessibility of the FCC's online public file system should be directed to the FCC at 888-225-5322, at 888-835-5322 (TTY) or at fccinfo@fcc.gov.