Bluefield pit bull owner's appeal denied - WVVA TV Bluefield Beckley WV News, Weather and Sports

Bluefield pit bull owner's appeal denied

Posted:
Estella Robinson Estella Robinson
  • More Local NewsMore Local NewsMore>>

  • UPDATE: Rail line reopens, derailment cleanup continues

    UPDATE: Rail line reopens, derailment cleanup continues

    ROCK (WVVA) - Crews were at the site of a train derailment in a remote area of Mercer County Wednesday. The derailment occurred Tuesday night in the Rock area -- near Montcalm -- across from Route 71..More >>
    ROCK (WVVA) - Crews were at the site of a train derailment in a remote area of Mercer County Wednesday. The derailment occurred Tuesday night in the Rock area -- near Montcalm -- across from Route 71.. More >>
  • Theatre W.Va. to return for 54th season

    Theatre W.Va. to return for 54th season

    BECKLEY, W.Va. (AP) -- Theatre West Virginia is preparing to return for its 54th season following a shutdown caused by financial problems.The Register-Herald reports that Theatre West Virginia has scheduled 17 performances of "Hatfields and McCoys" this season...More >>
    BECKLEY, W.Va. (AP) -- Theatre West Virginia is preparing to return for its 54th season following a shutdown caused by financial problems.The Register-Herald reports that Theatre West Virginia has scheduled 17 performances of "Hatfields and McCoys" this season...More >>
  • Woman guilty of four charges after running over employee

    Woman guilty of four charges after running over employee

    MERCER CO. (WVVA) - Dustie Beller was on trial for running over a woman with her car all for chainsaw. While she was found not guilty of attempted murder, the jury did find her guilty of petty larceny, conspiracy, failure to stop and render aid, and malicious wounding. The victim had this to say about the verdict. "Um very happy,” Mackenzie Ansley said. “To be expected -- the attempted murder charge. I knew coming into it, it was an iffy charge. And I'll take four out of five. And I'm happy w...More >>
    MERCER CO. (WVVA) - Dustie Beller was on trial for running over a woman with her car all for chainsaw. While she was found not guilty of attempted murder, the jury did find her guilty of petty larceny, conspiracy, failure to stop and render aid, and malicious wounding. The victim had this to say about the verdict. "Um very happy,” Mackenzie Ansley said. “To be expected -- the attempted murder charge. I knew coming into it, it was an iffy charge. And I'll take four out of five. And I'm happy w...More >>

BLUEFIELD (WVVA) - An appeal made by the owner of a pit bull that was ordered destroyed after it bit an animal control officer has been denied, court documents show.

Circuit Court Judge William Sadler issued the ruling on July 31, a week after he heard the appeal of the dog's owner, Estella Robinson.

View the court documents

Robinson's appeal had challenged the authority of the Municipal Court to enforce a city ordinance that "prohibits a person from keeping or harboring a vicious animal and allows a municipal judge to order the destruction of any animal determined to be vicious or dangerous."

Sadler ruled that the Municipal Court does have the power to enforce the ordinance and kill the animal.

On March 6, Randall Thompson, the City of Bluefield's Animal Control Officer, was bit by Robinson's pit bull while responding to a complaint at her residence.

In April, Robinson pleaded guilty in Municipal Court to owning a dangerous animal. Based upon the plea, the dog was ordered to be put down.

The order was stayed for 30 days to allow Robinson to find a suitable home for the animal outside of Bluefield on the condition that it could be determined that the dog could be rehabilitated.

In May, Robinson informed the Municipal Court that she had found a home outside of Bluefield for the dog, but did not have an expert's opinion that the dog could be rehabilitated to the point that it would not be a threat. The court again ordered the dog destroyed.

Robinson then filed an appeal with Mercer County Circuit Court, challenging the Municipal Court's authority.

That appeal was heard on July 24.

The court document emphasizes that the appeal was not whether or not the pit bull should be killed, but whether the Municipal Court has the authority to do so.

Powered by WorldNow
All content © Copyright 2000 - 2014 WorldNow and WVVA.
All Rights Reserved. For more information on this site, please read our Privacy Policy, Terms of Service and Mobile Privacy Policy & Terms of Service.

Persons with disabilities who need assistance with issues relating to the content of this station's public inspection file should contact Administrative Assistant Audrey Sluss at (304) 324-0659. Questions or concerns relating to the accessibility of the FCC's online public file system should be directed to the FCC at 888-225-5322, at 888-835-5322 (TTY) or at fccinfo@fcc.gov.